StafkaFind workPost a jobSign inGet 3 candidates

When a remote hire does not work out

Sometimes a hire who looked right in the interviews does not work out in practice. Acting early and fairly protects your business and the person, and keeps your options open: fix the problem, change the role, or part ways and find someone else. If you hired through Stafka and it is within 1801 days of the start date, the new search is free: one replacement per placement, once the placement fee has been paid and as long as the role, hours and pay stay as agreed; the fee itself is not refunded.

Published 7 November 2026· Updated 12 November 2026· Stafka editorial team· 4 min read

First, find the real cause

Before deciding about the person, check the things around them. A struggling hire is often partly a role or a management problem:

  • The role: is the scope written down, realistic for the hours and the same as what the offer promised?
  • The set-up: does the person have the access, tools, documentation and answers they need, in time?
  • The management: have they had specific feedback, with examples, early enough to act on it?
  • The person: skills, reliability, communication, or the fit with how you work.

If one of the first three is the problem, fix it first. If it is the fourth, be honest about it, and soon.

Have the direct conversation early

Raise the pattern on a call, not in a chat message, with two or three concrete examples and what good would have looked like. Then listen: there may be a reason you do not know about. Follow up in writing, so both of you have the same record.

Follow-up after the conversation

Thanks for the call today. To sum up what we discussed:

What is not working: [two or three specific examples].

What good looks like: [the standard, as concretely as possible].

What I will do: [support, answers, documentation].

Next check: [date], when we look at this together again.

A short improvement plan

If the gap can be closed, agree a short plan with one or two goals and a date a few weeks away. Keep the goals specific, such as “no calendar errors for three weeks” or “every ticket gets a first reply within the shift”, give the support you promised and check in weekly.

An improvement plan is a real chance, not a formality on the way out. If you have already decided, skip it and part ways fairly instead.

Change the role instead

Sometimes the person is good, just not at this. A support agent with excellent written English but little patience for live chat may be strong on email and the help centre; an assistant who struggles with a crowded calendar may be very good at research and documents. If you have that other work, a different scope can save the hire. Agree it in writing as a new scope, and if you hired through a recruiter, check how a change of role affects their terms.

Parting ways fairly

  1. Decide, then tell the person on a call, briefly and respectfully, with the reason.
  2. Give the notice the agreement states, or pay for it if you prefer the person to stop now.
  3. Agree the handover: open items, documents, logins in the vault.
  4. Pay the final invoice on time, including any days owed.
  5. Run the offboarding list on the last day; our security and access guide has it.
  6. Offer a reference for what went well, if you honestly can.

How you end a contract is noticed by the rest of your team and by future candidates. Fair and quick is kinder than slow and vague.

Using a replacement guarantee

If you hired through Stafka, tell us as soon as you see a pattern, not at the end. Sometimes a call with both sides clears up a mismatch in expectations; if it does not, we start a new search.

Stafka replaces the person free of charge if they leave or do not work out within 1801 days of the start date: one replacement per placement, once the placement fee has been paid and as long as the role, hours and pay stay as agreed. The fee itself is not refunded. With optional ongoing support at $2501 a month, a replacement is available at any time while the support is paid.

Before the new search, update the brief with what you learned: the skills that turned out to matter, the hours, the tools. The employer terms set out the replacement rules in full.

Questions

How long should I wait before deciding a remote hire is not working?

Not until the end of the trial. If the same problems continue for a few weeks after clear feedback, act. Our trial period guide sets checkpoints at 30, 60 and 90 days.

Do I have to pay for the notice period?

Pay what the agreement says. If you want the person to stop immediately, paying for the notice period instead of having it worked is usually the cleanest option.

Is the placement fee refunded if the hire leaves?

No. Stafka replaces the person instead, once per placement, within 1801 days of the start date, as long as the fee has been paid and the role, hours and pay stayed as agreed.

What should I tell the rest of the team?

Briefly, that the person has left and who takes over their work. Keep the reasons private.

General information for small employers, not legal or tax advice: check contracts, tax and data rules for your country with a qualified adviser. Figures carry their sources below; our own prices are on the pricing page. Spotted a mistake? Write to hello@stafka.com.

Sources

1 source, with links
  1. Stafka pricing: stafka.com

How these pages are built: methodology and data sources. Last updated 2026-11-12.